Pete’s Tavern is the “Oldest Original Bar in New York City – Opened 1864” according to the gold sign posted on the wall on your way to the toilet. I feel like this claim is made by at least 5 NYC Bars, but let’s just assume Pete’s is telling the truth.

Regardless, this place looks and smells OLD. I love it.

The veal meatball hero is animal suffering at it’s tastiest. I only order veal about once a year and always feel terribly guilty about doing so. Yet, I still order it. It’s just so…tasty (and cheap, only $9.50!)

The sandwiches all come with a small plate of both uninspired potato salad and bland cole slaw. Truly forgettable. thank goodness it’s not extra.

The veggie burger looked a bit frightening but I’m told it was delicious.

The salmon entrée is probably the last thing I would order but I did notice the plate was sufficiently cleared, so I’m assuming it wasn’t revolting.

Pete’s is great for an after work drink (as long as you don’t mind a crowd) but I love it for lunch when there’s nobody around. Quiet, peaceful, cheap and old.

Funny how I appreciate the same traits in a restaurant as I do in my grandma.

129 E 18th St
New York, NY 10003
b/t Irving Pl & 3rd Ave
Union Square, Gramercy, Flatiron
(212) 473-7676
petestavern.com

Grilled Salmon with Lentils

Veggie Burger with Goat Cheese

Veal Meatball Hero