I recently read an article describing the top 10 places in NYC that you should AVOID. And whadya know? Ellen’s Stardust Diner is one of them.
Yes. It’s 100% tourist attraction. There is nothing for a jaded New Yorker foodie.
But I came here when my mother and sister came to visit recently, so it was the perfect opportunity!
Was the food as bad as I was expecting? No. Did the cheese sauce on the nachos have a frightening pink hue? Yes. Was it still tasty? Yes.
The waitstaff all sing Broadway showtunes. That’s Ellen’s schtick. That’s why you’re waiting in that long ass line outside. And they’re really talented, I was shocked. I definitely expected more amateur karaoke action.
What is certainly hilarious is watching the servers ring up customers orders whilst sing and doing a little jig while bringing waters to a table. They definitely try their best not to appear bored but they clearly have all done this before. They are just this side of being over it.
A tip bucket will make it’s rounds but we happened to miss it during our meal.
Ellen’s is definitely an entertaining experience if you’re in the right mindset. If you’re a New Yorker wanting really good food and maybe have a hangover? Well, you wouldn’t be coming near Times Square anyways, now would you?
1650 Broadway
New York, NY 10019
b/t 51st St & 50th St
Theater District, Midtown West
(347) 504-6517
ellensstardustdiner.com