I think it’s pretty much been established that Di Fara’s pizza is the best in all of NYC. Just check out every single top 10 list on the internet.
Di Fara’s is old school. Like, the a one room school house from Little House on the Prairie, old school.
Eating here is like eating here in someone’s wood-paneled garage turned rec room. Paper plates, cheap napkins.
Awesome pizza.
It really is that good.
One man’s Pizza Picasso is another man’s Dominoes. Sometimes it depends on what you’re in the mood for. Greasy, thin, thick, tons of toppings, light on toppings. Sometimes you just want a frozen Mama Celeste’s pizza from Rite Aid.
Di Fara’s will only be the best pizza you’ve ever had if you’re in the mood for that type of pizza on that particular day. You picky b*tch.
Di Fara’s isn’t typical NY thin crust. It’s a bit thicker. It’s also a little fancier, the sauce doesn’t get spread out to the very edge. The owner, Dom, will snip fresh basil on it. Plus, it’s expensive. A full pizza costs $30. A slice costs $5.
These facts may turn you off. If they do, go and buy that Mama Celeste I was just talking about. In fact, pick one up for me, too.
I actually think I like Di Fara’s square pizza better. Just a little more saucy. And a little more expensive too. A slice costs $6 and a full square pizza is $34.
Di Fara’s opens at noon. Plan on arriving no later than 11:45 am so you can be one of the first in line, if you desire to eat in the next 30 minutes. The place is small, they only have two ovens and Dom is the only one making all the pizzas.
Or, like I’ve said repeatedly, go shove a Mama Celeste pizza in your mouth and shut up already.
Sorry, I think I’ve lived in NYC too long.
1424 Ave J
Brooklyn, NY 11230
Midwood
(718) 258-1367
difara.com