Rosie’s is a pretty solid new Mexican eatery in the East Village that’s spacious, lively and casual. Definitely recommended for brunch, but probably good anytime you’re in the mood for a tasty margarita without a douchy or pretentious scene.
I don’t know how much longer they’ll be serving the summery watermelon margaritas (the better of the two I tried) but they were fantastic. Instead of being overly sweet, they really had a boozy kick. This appears to be unusual in most fruity margaritas I’ve tried in the past.
The Habanero Mango marg was tasty, but on the thick side. The mango puree wasn’t diluted enough for my liking. I didn’t try the regular margs, but would definitely go back and try them.
Margs.
As far as the brunch fare goes, the scrambled eggs and green chorizo were definitely a highlight. Simple but very tasty and served with homemade tortillas. You know they’re homemade, because situated in the center of the restaurant is an enclosure where two women of Hispanic origin are making tortillas right before your very eyes.
Unless this little act is just for show?
Perhaps, a little entertainment and then all the tortillas are promptly thrown in the trash and cheap .99 tortillas on the verge of becoming rotten are microwaved for a few second to revive them before being served to unsuspecting customers.
In many cases, a tortilla is just a tortilla. Rarely, have I been wowed by one.
Where was I?
Ok, so the chilaquiles were just ok. They were a bit on the carby side, not a lot of much else going on but tortillas. Needed a more eggy or saucy presence. The dish looked pretty, and was topped with a fried egg but only order this if you’re in the mood to carb load.
The tacos were on the smaller side but not overpriced for the setting. $8 for two tacos is acceptable for NYC. $14 for two tacos is more common and NOT acceptable.
Whatever you do, do not order the Fruit Cocktail (Coctel de Frutas). It’s just a big sundae glass of boring fruit topped with cinnamon and some kind of syrup at the bottom. And it’s $9. Definitely overpriced and a bit odd.
We all agreed that the best dish were the potato croquettes. Crispy on the outside, creamy on the inside, these were like what I wish all Latkes tasted like, but never do. And only $5 bucks. These are a must order.
29 E Second St
New York, NY 10003
East Village
(212) 335-0114
rosiesnyc.com
Watermelon Margarita – $13
Mexican 75 – Ancho Reyes Liqueur, Fresh Lime, Cava Rosado, Dry Curacao – $12
Mango Habanero Margarita – $13
Coctel de Frutas: Fresh Fruit & piloncillo syrup – $9
Tortitas de Papas: Potato Croquettes – $5
Chilaquiles – sunnyside eggs, smokey roasted tomatillo salsa, Chihuahua cheese, tortilla chips, pickled jalapenos & red onions – $14
Al Pastor Tacos – $8
Huevos con Chorizo Verde: Scrambled Eggs, Green Chorizo Sausage, cucumber radish salad – $13